Pundit responds to the most recent news about Alex Neil and Birmingham City, saying, “Great appointment”
Written by Brett Worthington
PUBLISHED 26 MINUTES AGO Carlton Palmer talked with FLW about his possible appointment of Alex Neil by Birmingham City.
Stoke City’s Alex Neil Highlights
Alex Neil is the front-runner for Birmingham City’s management position because of his successful promotions in the past and his strategic approach.
The young players at Birmingham City could benefit from Neil’s expertise in the EFL and perhaps support in the transfer market the following season.
Neil’s appointment, in spite of his prior employment at Stoke City, makes sense in light of Birmingham’s desire to advance and stay out of League One.
Alex Neil, in the opinion of former England midfielder Carlton Palmer, would be a fantastic addition to Birmingham City.
The Blues are searching for a new manager as the summer approaches, following Tony Mowbray’s announcement that he will not be rejoining the team.
Gary Rowett was Birmingham City’s manager until the end of the season, however the team finished in 22nd place, one point outside of safety, and he was unable to keep them in the Championship
As a result, the Blues will play in League One starting in 2024–2025, and it appears Neil will be leading them from the dugout.
John Percy disclosed last week that Neil had discussed the managerial job with Birmingham City and was thought to be a good fit.
After interviewing for the manager’s position, Football Insider has subsequently stated that Neil has become the clear favorite for the position.
According to Carlton Palmer, Alex Neil would be a fantastic addition to Birmingham City.
Management at Carlton Palmer
Here, we questioned Carlton Palmer, a former player for Sheffield Wednesday, about his opinion of Alex Neil leading Birmingham City into the managerial position.
Palmer revealed to Football League World in an exclusive interview that Alex Neil is expected to take over as Birmingham City’s next head coach.
Alex Neil left Stoke City in December 2023 and hasn’t had a job since. Neil has demonstrated his competence. He left Sunderland after he helped them advance because sometimes going to a football club doesn’t work.
“Everyone assumed he would stay, but perhaps it was just Sunderland’s decision-making process and the way things were going at the time.
Working with the younger players rather than the more seasoned players, and perhaps Alex reasoned that at Stoke City he would have a larger budget to work with.
“He signed players, but things didn’t work out for him. That being said, he did an excellent job at Sunderland and Preston.”
He has demonstrated tactical shrewdness throughout his managing career, thus I believe Birmingham City made a wise hire in him.
“Wayne Rooney came in, and I think it wasn’t as clear-cut as that dismissing Eustace, but Birmingham failed with the awful judgment about John Eustace last season. I think they intended to bring Wayne Rooney in the summer, but he was unable to do so until his contract in America expired.
The club was in the top six at the time under John Eustace’s leadership. After that, they let Rooney leave, and sadly, Tony Mowbray got sick.
“I don’t think they would have been demoted if Mowbray had been the manager instead. Sadly, Tony’s condition is now being treated, thus they will need to name a new boss.
“If Akex Neil receives support in the transfer market, I believe he is a great addition.” He’s shown that he can manage younger players. Former Sunderland player Pritchard, who flourished under Neil at Sunderland, has struggled to get going at Birmingham City. However, I’m sure he will be happy to see Alex Neil, and Birmingham supporters will get to see the best of him next season.
The St Andrew’s Stadium Connection
Tottenham, Chelsea, and Manchester United plan a move to Birmingham City.
This summer, Birmingham City will have to battle to hold onto one of their most potential young players. The appointment of Alex Neil makes sense for Birmingham City.
Stoke City’s Alex Neil
The appointment of Alex Neil as Birmingham City’s new manager would be a wise decision for the team.
Given that his tenure at Stoke City wasn’t particularly successful, Neil is likely someone that not many Blues supporters have given much thought to.
Looking past that period, though, the Scotsman has had a pretty successful management career in England.
Neil accomplished a great job at Preston and has managed promotions at Hamilton, Norwich City, and Sunderland.
He managed promotion with the Black Cats during their League One season, despite his brief tenure in the EFL, and he has proven to be an effective player. Given his expertise at that level and his knowledge of how to exit the league, Birmingham most likely took him into consideration for the position.
Birmingham City needs that, and pursuing someone like Neil makes perfect sense since they cannot afford to stay in that tier.
